Remove or disable completed ideas from list

  11 years ago
  Under dev. review

Ideas that have been implemented, approved or rejected should be either removed from the list or disabled for comments and voting to allow new ideas to move up the list.
Latest comments
Qruqs 8 years ago

I think they should be moved to a completely different part of the site, that has nothing to do with this idea business. Like implemented user ideas, or whatever. Therefore demoted.

Mintification 9 years ago

Great idea indeed.

sunewbie 9 years ago

+1 promoting

dagon 9 years ago

Similar/same ideas rejected:

blueXrider 10 years ago

Agreed, when is it going to be implemented?

RedGhost 10 years ago

or at least be marked in some way to inform of status.

passstab 10 years ago

i think new means new but implemented, approved or rejected ideas aren't
put in there respective catagory oftan enouph

orionthehunter 10 years ago

New ideas should move up the list when others have been approved, rejected, or implemented, but old ones should not be removed in my opinion.

frankeinstein 10 years ago

Totally agree. I love reading all members ideas and I do try to read through as many pages of them as I can in one sitting, but this really would tidy up the list and make it much easier to view new ideas.

remoulder 11 years ago

@Rovanion: The 'New' really seems to mean all ideas, and as the default sort is 'Top Rated' this means the same ideas always appear at the top of the list when you first go to Ideas, even if they've already been implemented, approved or rejected. People being people, most users probably never go beyond the first 1 or 2 pages, so it's likely many ideas are never seen or voted on. As there seems little point in voting or commenting on ideas that have already been approved, implemented or rejected, these ideas should be removed or disabled from further voting.

Rovanion 11 years ago

Correct me if I'm wrong but: When you search for ideas, by default, only ideas that are of the status "New" are shown.

What list are you speaking of and why do they need to be removed?

Fr3d 11 years ago

yes good idea so the list is more relevant and manageable.

lnxwalt 11 years ago

On the other hand, if they are removed completely, others will re-request them. They need to be out of the way of active ideas, without being hidden or hard to access.

RayWoods 11 years ago

Yes, get rid of the clutter.