10 years ago
I get all notifications to the ideas and tutorials that I comment.
I do not get a notification when someone votes but does not comment. I do not find any need to get notifications get one only votes.
I always subscribe to all ideas I comment even if I demote it. There is always scope of discussion. Sometimes idea is modified or you change your mind and change your vote too.
I am suggesting you subscribe by default and have an unsubscribe button. Because, i may not be an expert on people behavior, but if someone has dismissed an idea and demoted it, i doubt that person is going to subscribe to it and will definitely miss any changes.
There is already a subscribe button that does this, what are you suggesting that is different?